| Butler Case |
 |
| B: |
1720 |
| P: |
Suffolk, New York, British Colonial America |
| D: |
1802 |
| P: |
Westmoreland, Pennsylvania, United States |
|
| Theophilus Case, Jr. |
 |
| B: |
1684 |
| P: |
Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America |
| M: |
|
| P: |
|
| D: |
22 Jul 1762 |
| P: |
Roxbury Township, Morris, New Jersey, British Colonial Americ |
|
| Theophilus Case, Sr. |
 |
| B: |
5 Jul 1661 |
| P: |
Southold, Suffolk, New York Colony, British Colonial America |
| M: |
|
| P: |
|
| D: |
28 Jul 1762 |
| P: |
Roxbury Township, Morris, New Jersey, British Colo |
|
| Henry William Case |
=> |
 |
| B: |
1632 |
| P: |
Southold, Suffolk, New York, British Colonial America |
| M: |
|
| P: |
|
| D: |
1665 |
| P: |
Southold, Long Island, Colony of New York, British Colonial A |
|